Backlinks are a critical factor in SEO, helping search engines understand your website’s authority and relevance. However, not all links are created equal.
Some links are editorial, naturally earned because your content provides value, while others are non-editorial, often created through paid, reciprocal, or automated methods.
Understanding the difference between editorial and non-editorial links is essential for building a safe, effective link-building strategy.
Editorial links improve your site’s credibility, authority, and search rankings, while non-editorial links can carry risks if overused or low-quality.
In this guide, we’ll explain what editorial and non-editorial links are, highlight their key differences, and show how to earn high-quality editorial links that support long-term SEO growth.
What Are Editorial Links?
Editorial links are backlinks that are naturally earned because your content provides genuine value to readers. They are not paid for, requested through manipulation, or exchanged inappropriately; they are given voluntarily by other website owners, editors, or bloggers.
Key points about editorial links:
- Earned Naturally – Linked because your content is useful, informative, or insightful.
- High Authority – Typically come from reputable, relevant websites in your niche.
- Google-Approved – Seen as trustworthy by search engines, boosting SEO and credibility.
-
Examples Include:
- Guest posts on industry blogs
- Resource page mentions
- Citations in articles or research studies
- Unlinked brand mentions turned into backlinks
Editorial links are highly valuable for SEO because they improve your site’s authority, relevance, and search ranking potential without risking penalties.
What Are Non-Editorial Links?
Non-editorial links are backlinks that are not earned naturally. They are often created through paid arrangements, reciprocal agreements, or automated methods, rather than being voluntarily given due to the value of your content.
Key points about non-editorial links:
- Not Naturally Earned – Created through payment, link exchanges, or mass submissions.
- Lower Authority – Often come from less relevant or lower-quality sites.
- Risk Factor – Overusing them can trigger Google penalties or reduce trust.
-
Examples Include:
- Paid links and advertisements
- Footer or sidebar sitewide links
- Forum or directory submissions
- Reciprocal link swaps
While non-editorial links can sometimes drive traffic, they offer less SEO value and may be risky if used excessively.
Key Differences Between Editorial and Non-Editorial Links
Understanding the differences helps in building a safe and effective link-building strategy:
-
Natural vs Artificial
- Editorial links are earned naturally due to valuable content.
- Non-editorial links are often paid, exchanged, or automated.
-
Authority & Trust
- Editorial links come from reputable, relevant websites and boost credibility.
- Non-editorial links may come from low-quality or unrelated sites, offering limited SEO value.
-
Google Perception
- Editorial links are favored by Google and improve rankings safely.
- Non-editorial links can be risky if overused and may trigger penalties.
-
Long-Term Value
- Editorial links provide sustainable SEO benefits and strengthen domain authority.
- Non-editorial links offer short-term traffic but limited long-term SEO impact.
-
Relationship Focus
- Editorial links often build genuine relationships with industry experts or bloggers.
- Non-editorial links usually do not foster long-term connections.
Key Takeaway: Focusing on editorial links ensures safer, more authoritative, and long-lasting SEO results, while non-editorial links should be used cautiously.
Why Editorial Links Matter More for SEO
Editorial links are considered the gold standard in link building because they offer long-term value and credibility. Here’s why they matter:
- Boost Authority – Links from reputable, relevant sites improve your domain authority.
- Enhance Trust & Credibility – Google and users see editorial links as endorsements of your content.
- Support E-E-A-T – Editorial links strengthen Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness.
- Long-Term SEO Benefits – Unlike non-editorial links, editorial links continue to support rankings over time.
- Improve Relevance – Links from contextually related content signal topical relevance to search engines.
In short, editorial links are safer, more authoritative, and more impactful for SEO than non-editorial links, making them the most valuable type of backlinks for long-term growth.
When Non-Editorial Links Can Still Be Useful
Although editorial links are more valuable, non-editorial links can have certain uses when applied carefully:
- Traffic Generation – Non-editorial links in directories, forums, or partner sites can drive visitors.
- Brand Awareness – Paid or reciprocal links can increase visibility to target audiences.
- Supplementary SEO – When combined with strong editorial links, they can provide minor SEO support.
- Safe Low-Risk Use – Use them sparingly from relevant, quality sources to avoid penalties.
Key Tip: Non-editorial links should never replace editorial links; they are best used as a complementary strategy rather than a primary link-building method.
How to Get More Editorial Links
Earning editorial links requires creating value and building genuine relationships. Here’s a step-by-step approach:
-
Create High-Quality Content
- Develop guides, research, infographics, or tools that are useful, unique, and shareable.
-
Identify Relevant Websites
- Target blogs, publications, and resource pages that are topically related to your niche.
-
Build Relationships
- Engage with editors, bloggers, and industry influencers through comments, social media, or networking.
-
Personalized Outreach
- Send individualized emails highlighting how your content adds value to their audience.
-
Offer Guest Posts or Expert Insights
- Contribute quality content or original research that fits the host site naturally.
-
Leverage Mentions
- Reach out to sites that mention your brand or content but haven’t linked, and request a backlink.
-
Track and Follow Up
- Monitor responses, maintain relationships, and nurture long-term connections for future opportunities.
By following these steps, you can earn high-quality editorial links that improve authority, boost SEO, and enhance your website’s credibility over time.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Even with editorial link-building efforts, certain mistakes can reduce effectiveness or harm SEO:
- Ignoring Relevance – Linking to or targeting unrelated sites reduces value and credibility.
- Generic Outreach Emails – Sending mass, impersonal emails can be flagged as spam.
- Over-Optimizing Anchor Text – Excessive exact-match keywords can appear manipulative.
- Buying Links – Paid links are considered non-editorial and can risk penalties.
- Neglecting Relationships – Failing to build genuine connections may limit future link opportunities.
- Ignoring Guidelines – Not following a website’s editorial or submission rules can harm reputation.
Avoiding these mistakes ensures that your outreach remains ethical, effective, and Google-safe, helping you earn high-quality editorial links consistently.
Final Thoughts
Understanding the difference between editorial and non-editorial links is essential for building a safe and effective SEO strategy.
Editorial links, earned naturally through valuable content and genuine outreach, improve your website’s authority, credibility, and search rankings.
Non-editorial links, while occasionally useful for traffic or brand visibility, offer limited SEO value and may carry risks if overused.
Focusing on earning high-quality editorial links through white-hat outreach ensures long-term SEO growth, enhances trust with search engines and users, and strengthens your website’s online reputation.
By avoiding common mistakes and prioritizing relevance and value, your link-building strategy can remain both ethical and highly effective.